Skip to content

The Disappearance of Caitlin Potts

Click here to hear the Audio File of this case. And please do not forget to subscribe to the podcast and leave us a review. Positive reviews really help others find our show.

Case File Overview

27-year-old Caitlin Potts went missing on February 22, 2016. The Sampson Cree First Nation mother was last seen at a mall in Kelowna B.C. the day before her disappearance. The final contact Caitlin had with friends or family was on the morning of February 22, 2016 when she sent her sister Codi a Facebook message.

Caitlin was reported missing to the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) on March 1, 2016. However, an official missing alert on the RCMP’s website was not posted until March 21, 2016. The alert read, “The RCMP Major Crimes Unit is now assisting Vernon North Okanagan RCMP with the investigation of Potts.”

By May 2017 the RCMP publicly stated, “We believe this is likely a homicide. She has likely met with foul play.”

The police released a surveillance video of Caitlin entering Orchard Park Mall in Kelowna, B.C. on February 21, 2016. This is the last known image of Caitlin. Staff Sgt. Annie Linteau explained that the purpose of releasing the video was “to provide a visual reminder to the public of Caitlin’s appearance and show what she may have been wearing near the time of her disappearance.”

Caitlin is approximately 160 cm (5’3″) and 68 kg (150 lbs). She has brown eyes and long black hair with blonde streaks.

Caitlin Potts 

Image of missing person Caitlin Potts
Image source: CBC News

Case File Theories


A Kijiji ad led to Caitlin’s murder

The morning Caitlin went missing she sent her sister Codi a message. The message said that she’d found a ride to Calgary through a Kijiji ad. Caitlin also told her sister she would be “coming back tonight for sure.” Additionally, she sent her roommate a message saying that she was off to Calgary after finding a ride through Kijiji.

Although it’s possible Caitlin was killed on the way to Calgary by the person who posted the Kijiji ad, the police have made it clear that they have no evidence that Caitlin ever headed to Calgary. In fact, investigators believe Caitlin never left the North Okanagan before her disappearance.

This leaves me wondering if whoever murdered Caitlin used her phone to contact her friends and family to mislead the police. If so, then Caitlin was likely killed by someone she knew. The person would’ve needed to have known who to contact.

A serial killer is on the loose in the North Okanagan

Two other women have recently gone missing from the North Okanagan. Is a serial killer at work in the region?

Deanne Wertz 

Image of missing person Deanna Mildred Wertz
Image source: CBC News

Deanne Wertz was last seen in the wee morning hours of July 19, 2016 at her home on Yankee Flats Road. She is 46 years old and First Nations. Deanne is 158 cm (5’2″) and 54 kg (120 lbs). Deanne disappeared after going on a hike, and police do not consider her disappearance the result of a homicide.

Ashley Simpson

Image of missing person Ashley Simpson
Image source: CBC News

On April 30, 2016 Ashley Simpson was reported missing to the Vernon-North Okanagan RCMP. Ashley is 165 cm (5’5″) and 54 kg (119 lbs). She has brown eyes and long brown hair. The police have stated that they believe Ashley’s disappearance could be the result of foul play.

A walk was organized in the region by Megan Louis to “bring more awareness to the public and to put more pressure on the RCMP and those investigating this case to do more on their part to find these women.”

After the walk Megan focused on erecting large billboards along the highways in the North Okanagan to spread the word about the missing women.

Even though the authorities suspect foul play in both Ashley’s and Caitlin’s disappearance, they’re adamant that the cases are not linked. A serial killer could be killing dark-haired women in the North Okanagan, but I think it’s unlikely.

Caitlin was murdered by her boyfriend

Jason Robert Hnatiuk

Image of Jason Robert Hnatiuk, man charged with assault of Caitlin Potts, a missing person in BC
Image source: CBC News

Caitlin moved to the North Okanagan to be close to her boyfriend, Jason Robert Hnatiuk. The media reported that “the two had a turbulent relationship over the years and had been on and off together for about two months before she disappeared.”

Codi, Caitlin’s sister, has stated that Jason was physically abusive; she often saw her sister in tears and covered in bruises. Detailing a past incident of abuse, Codi said, “One time she called me crying and she was hiding in the bathroom, saying he was outside and he was going to kick the door in.” Jason was arrested after this altercation and Caitlin spent some time in a women’s shelter.

Mainly as result of video surveillance footage from an incident that occurred on August 24, 2014 between Jason and Caitlin, on May 16, 2017 Jason was convicted of assault with a weapon and breaching his no contact order.

Jason contacted the media and denied ever being Caitlin’s boyfriend, insisted she didn’t live with him (but conceded she occasionally stayed over), and stated that Caitlin worked as an escort. Jason complained that he’s been questioned by the police repeatedly and feels he’s being treated unfairly. He also said he can’t recall when he last spoke with or saw Caitlin.

The police won’t say if Jason is a suspect in Caitlin’s disappearance and suspected murder.

Given Jason’s violent treatment of Caitlin, I strongly suspect that he may have played a role in her disappearance. Sadly, as we’ve seen in many of the cases previously covered, when a woman disappears or is killed, it’s often at the hands of her partner or a man known to her.

What do you think happened to Caitlin Potts?

Caitlin is described as being incredibly smart, happy, outgoing, and family-oriented. She’s deeply missed by her family, friends, and community.

Like many other cases of missing and murdered Indigenous women in Canada, Caitlin’s case does not receive as much public attention as it should. A black mark on Canada is, without doubt, our horrific treatment of Indigenous Peoples. In part to combat the systemic racism that hinders closure in cases involving Indigenous women and girls, the Canadian Federal government formed the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and GirlsCBC News, Canada’s largest news outlet, has also focused on missing and murdered Indigenous women and girls by starting an excellent and informative website that investigates their cases: Missing & Murdered: The Unsolved Cases of Indigenous Women and Girls.

Caitlin’s mother Pricilla recently explained, “It’s been really, really hard for all of us. A lot of people don’t understand what I am going through.” Caitlin’s family deserves to know what happened to Caitlin and need at least some kind of closure in this case. Please help get justice for Caitlin by spreading the word about her case.

Anyone with information regarding Caitlin’s disappearance is asked to contact the Vernon RCMP at 250-545-7171 or Crime Stoppers at 1-888-222-8477.

Related Reading

Missing & Murdered: The Unsolved Cases of Indigenous Women and GirlsCBC News website

“Caitlin Potts left sister chilling last message before she disappeared from B.C. Interior”CBC News article

“Caitlin Potts’ unsolved case: Do you recognize her in this video?”CBC News article

“UPDATE: ‘I wasn’t her boyfriend:’ Man convicted of Caitlin Potts assault explains”CBC News article

Interested in unsolved cases? Check out the disappearance of Roberta Marie Sims and the mysterious murder of Veronica Kaye.

Liked it? Take a second to support Christine on Patreon!
Published inMissing Person FilesTrue Crime



  1. Jedi Jedi

    I think the boyfriend killed her. Why else lie about their relationship? If she had been an escort, as he claimed, the agency would have blacklisted him from using their services after he assaulted Caitlyn.
    Additionally, Jasons statement to the media was all about himself and how he is a victim. Nothing about hoping Caitlyn is found alive and well or her killer brought to justice.

    • Christine Christine

      Thanks for reading and for taking the time to reply. You ask good questions that I hope the police are investigating!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© 2023 The True Crime Files. All Rights Reserved.

Don’t miss a case! Subscribe to The TCF Newsletter to receive an article roundup, true crime news, and special offers.


Pin It on Pinterest